Verified Document

Identity Williams On Identity In A Series Essay

Identity Williams on Identity

In a series of relatively simple though complexly-worded (out of necessity) thought experiments regarding body-swapping and changes to memory and the mind, Bernard Williams attempts to demonstrate that identity should be identified with the body rather than with the mind when identity is extended into the future (and by extension during the present). Whether or not Williams is successful in this attempt is a matter of much debate, with this author finding some fundamental flaws in the very premise of the comparisons and thus the conclusions, however the argument is fairly elegant and persuasive and certainly worth of closer inspection. A careful reading of the argument might lead one to a conclusion opposite to that which was intended, but is no less rewarding for this unusual quirk.

Williams begins by dispensing with several considerations that are not germane to his argument, and while some could find room to quibble with these dispensations they truly are not of importance to Williams' central argument or its flaws. Getting to the heart of the matter, Williams assumes that there are two people, a and B, have agreed to take part in an experiment wherein a's mind will be transferred into B's body and vice-versa -- a case of body-swapping....

Williams concludes, and it can be agreed, that a will rationally believe that he will occupy B's body -- that his identity will be transferred into the other's body along with his mind -- and that B. will similarly conceive of an identity transfer, as well. a-body-person, identified by the body of the person that was a prior to the experiment, will have B's mind and identity, that is, while B-body-person (the physical body of the person identified as B. prior to the experiment) will contain the mind and identity of a.
This appears a rational conclusion to Williams, and so he proceeds to imagine that prior to the experiment both persons a and B. will be asked to give a preference for one of two outcomes following the experiment: A-body-person can be given $100,000 while B-body-person is tortured, or B-body-person can be given the $100,000 while a-body-person is tortured. As the rational projection of identity in this scenario is for a to assume he will be B-body-person and for B. To assume that he will be a-body-person, each would rationally and selfishly be expected to show a preference for the outcome in which their old body received the torture while their new body -- along with their mind and identity -- received the $100,000. This cements the projection of identity as traveling with the mind; believing that he will occupy B's body and therefore be B-body-person, a will choose for a-body-person to receive…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

David Hume/Williams James William James
Words: 2661 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

James believed that belief in God could be contemplated in terms of "live and dead hypotheses" (James 2010). He argues that when one is trying to find an argument for God existing or God not existing, we must consider three things: 1) Living or dead 2) Forced or unavoidable; and, 3) Momentous or trivial. He says, "and for our purposes we may call an option a genuine option when it

Luxury Fashion of Swarovski Toward
Words: 5498 Length: 17 Document Type: Literature Review

"The second step is to develop a touch-point chain and gauge those with the greatest impact. The third step is to turn findings into project priorities. The final step is to implement and monitor." (Atwal and Williams, 2009 P. 343). Uche (2009) provides different argument by pointing out that internet experience create compelling, enjoyable, memorable, and positive experience for online shoppers. The author develops web experience model to demonstrate the

Colombia Is the Third-Largest Recipient
Words: 19788 Length: 58 Document Type: Research Proposal

During this penultimate period of violence under Rojas, the violence that wracked Colombia assumed a number of different characteristics that included an economic quality as well as a political one with numerous assassinations taking place. These were literally contract killings there were sponsored by opposition forms. There were also horrendous genocidal acts that were carried out by gangs combined with authentic revolutionary fighting in some regions of the country. The fourth

Asher Lev Just As One
Words: 4145 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Such relationships in childhood begin with the parents, and for Asher, these early relationships are also significant later, as might be expected. However, as Potok shows in this novel, for someone like Asher, the importance of childhood bonds and of later intimate bonds are themselves stressed by cultural conflicts between the Hasidic community in its isolation and the larger American society surrounding it. For Asher, the conflict is between the

Close Comparison -- Compare and Contrast Comparison
Words: 759 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Close Comparison -- Compare and Contrast Comparison of Solomon-Godeau and Williams Photography is an ethically complex art: unlike a painting which purports to be the work of an individual artist and reaffirm his or her 'true self,' a photograph at least superficially suggests that it has encapsulated 'the real.' The impression of reality conveyed by photography is so persuasive that the fact that a photograph is still one interpretation amongst many may

Technology Issue in Information Assurance
Words: 3012 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

S. Department of Defense (DOD) uses over two million computers and more than ten thousand local area networks, most of which are linked to, and vulnerable to attack from, users of the larger Internet. (2008, p. 276) These increasing threats correspond to the growing reliance on information systems to manage the entire spectrum of modern commerce and energy resources, making the disruption of a single element in the integrated system a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now